Today, I was accused of being a control freak, it was said in jest following a flippant comment I had made. It did however lead onto a conversation about control and whether we can control others, whether we have power over other people or not. One of my companions, let’s call her Sam, a very self-assured woman who has to my knowledge never in her entire life suffered a moment of self-doubt (and if she has she certainly wouldn’t admit to it) claimed that we could not control anyone else. According to Sam it may seem like people control us at times, often women will complain of their husbands being controlling, but in reality we allow people to control us. We hand over our power, we submit to their wishes and demands, we do not stand up for ourselves and what we want.
She frequently dominates the conversation at our coffee mornings, she is very confident and articulate, has a wonderful way with anecdotes and is very much aware that she will often control the conversation. She even used herself as an example, saying that the rest of us would sit there and allow her to talk, to interrupt or to change the subject without challenging her. In her view she was not controlling (or domineering), it was that we were being submissive, allowing her to do so. If no one challenged then she assumed that we were happy to sit and listen to her, to discuss the topics she wanted to discuss.
Another woman put forward the argument that actually a lot of the time she did not feel confident enough to object, to say “may I finish please?” when interrupted, that she felt by doing so she was putting herself in the spotlight, attracting unwanted attention or even somehow being pathetic when someone else obviously wanted to say something they felt important. Sam, however, pointed out that others’ insecurities were not her problem, that if we decided to give up and not challenge that was entirely up to us.
I then pointed out that we had all known each other for years, and knew each other idiosyncrasies and that we should make allowances for each other. When we know someone is shy, or lacks confidence it does not give us an excuse to run roughshod over them, in fact we should be encouraging them to express their opinions, to nurture them and thus build their confidence. If you not do that then we are being controlling, or domineering, as we are putting ourselves and our wants and needs before everyone else’s.
Needless to say, Sam did not agree with me on that point and someone else decided it was time to step in and change the subject as the discussion was getting rather heated.
It did however give me plenty of food for thought. I wonder when we do not challenge behaviour we do not like, for whatever reason, is that giving up our power, are we actually allowing ourselves to be controlled?
I believe that people can control others, not directly or immediately, it is a constant drip feed until the weaker person is so worn down they no longer have the strength to fight back, they turn in on themselves and give in to it because they longer value themselves, they have been told time and time again that they do not count, that their wishes, needs and wants are not important. We cannot control people as we do the TV or a car, it is done subtly but it can be done. More often that not the person doing the controlling will not or cannot admit to it. Often they do not recognise what they are doing, because their own insecurities lead to this behaviour, making another feel weak makes them feel stronger. Such is their need to feel superior that any love or empathy they should feel for the other is subjugated by their desire to be seen to be better than them.